Inclusion. Musk said it himself (call, keynote, interview, post), it carries a date or a window that can be resolved from the day he said it ("next year", "in three months", "end of Q2"), the outcome is checkable, and there is a source. Undated aspirations are out. Political and government claims (DOGE) are excluded by scope. A promise re-made with a new date counts as a new claim; the earlier one is graded on its own deadline.
Grades. On time and in full: delivered at roughly 90% or more of the promise by the end of the stated period. Late, in full: delivered in full after the deadline. Partial: the deadline passed and materially less was delivered, but at least a tenth of the promise; a token delivery below that counts as missed. Missed: the deadline passed and it is still not delivered. Goalposts moved: restated with a later date before the original deadline arrived, and judged only once that original deadline has passed. Open: the deadline has not arrived. "Unsupervised" self-driving claims are not met by supervised or safety-monitor operation.
Demonstrated or novel. Demonstrated means the thing already worked at least once and the claim was about scaling or scheduling it. Novel means a first.
Verification. Every missed claim plus a stratified sample of 96 records (98 in all, two later excluded) was re-checked by independent fact-checkers working from the grading rules, not from the original research. 68 of 98 were confirmed as written, 19 had details corrected with the grade unchanged, and 6 were regraded (most often a 'goalposts moved' that should be 'pending' or a slip that turned out to be a pre-deadline restatement). Two claims were excluded: one whose attribution to Musk could not be confirmed and one that was a conditional opinion rather than a dated promise. Checked records carry a 'checked' badge in the explorer.
Next Level Side NoteA ledger like this is only as good as its inclusion bar. Loosen it to every "soon" and "probably" and the hit rate falls further; tighten it to dated earnings-call guidance and it rises. This one uses the same bar as the SpaceX claims ledger in the GAMMERS run, so the two can be compared. (If you disagree with a grade, the quote and both sources are one click away in the explorer.)